Bite Back Bakehouse / Catering + Big Orders
Feed the
whole damn
crew.
Office breakfast, birthday, shower, client gifts, wedding recovery brunch, or the party you forgot you offered to host, we've got bagels, sourdough, cookies and custom treats for people who deserve better than grocery-store catering.
Small-batch baked in West Haven, ConnecticutYou bring the people, we'll bring the goods
What's the occasion?
Whether you're feeding the office or pulling off something a little more personal, we'll help build an order that fits the crowd, the budget and the occasion.
Office + teams
Breakfast meetings, employee treats, recurring orders and client drop-offs.
Parties + celebrations
Birthdays, showers, graduations and backyard chaos worth feeding people for.
Events + favors
Cookie trays, individually wrapped treats, welcome bags and green-room snacks.
Gifts + thank-yous
Client boxes, host gifts and apologies that should probably arrive with cookies.
The catering lineup
Choose your headliners.
Pick one category or mix a few together. We can quote standard quantities, custom assortments, special packaging and event-specific requests.

Cookie boxes + trays
Our 90g cookies, specialty bakes, sandwich cookies and jumbo options, offered as boxes, trays, individually wrapped favors or one very good reason to show up at a party.
See cookie options ↗
Bagel boxes + breakfast
Hand-rolled sourdough bagels, mixed flavors, scones and rotating breakfast bakes for meetings, showers, brunches and people who take breakfast seriously.
See breakfast options ↗
Sourdough + bread orders
Classic sourdough loaves and seasonal breads for family meals, holidays, gift boxes, grazing tables and larger orders.
See bread options ↗
The full Bite Back spread
Can't commit to one category? Combine cookies, bagels, breads and seasonal treats into a custom order, with quantities and packaging tailored to your event.
Let's build it ↗Cookie boxes / Parties / Events / Gifting
Cookies for the whole crowd.
Whether you need a dozen for a team meeting or enough for the entire guest list, we'll help you build the right assortment. Our standard cookie boxes have straightforward pricing, while bigger, more customized requests are quoted individually.
Everyday cookie boxes
Standard pricing applies to eligible regular-size cookies. Flavor selection depends on what's available.
Catering + big orders
Quotes consider quantities, flavor selection, specialty ingredients, production requirements, presentation and packaging. Larger orders do not automatically receive discounted pricing.
The Cookie Vault / Flavors past, present + rotating
Pick your poison.
We've built a pretty ridiculous collection of cookies, from the classics everyone knows and loves to combinations that sounded questionable on paper but turned out to be excellent decisions. Browse the lineup, find your favorites and tell us what you're craving.
Variety is the spice of life, but so is sanity.
We love a good assortment, and we completely understand wanting to try a little bit of everything. Because everything is made in small batches, standard catering selections require a minimum of four cookies per flavor. Not every flavor is in rotation every week, and availability is confirmed when we review your request.
Want more variety without committing to multiple separate batches? Ask about our Baker's Choice assortment, featuring flavors already on the baking schedule. Have a specific request that falls outside the standard guidelines? We're happy to explore it and provide a custom quote.
Explore the flavors
Open a category to read about each cookie ↓
The OGs / Classics
Chocolate Chip
Sourdough brown butter chocolate chip cookie finished with a touch of salt, a familiar classic with a more grown-up side.
Campfire
Sourdough brown butter cookie stuffed with marshmallows, baked on graham crackers and topped with Hershey’s chocolate.
M&M
Our sourdough brown butter cookie loaded with colorful M&M candies.
Mixed Signals
Sourdough brown butter cookie packed with peanut M&Ms.
Raisin Hell
An oatmeal-based raisin cookie, for the people who will defend oatmeal raisin until the bitter end.
Brookie
A brownie-based cookie that brings chocolate-cookie and brownie energy into one bake.
Sugar We’re Going Down
A sugar cookie from the classic side of our lineup, with a name that belongs on your old playlist.
Bite Back Specials
Turtle Pecan
Our sourdough brown butter base with caramel and pecans, inspired by the classic turtle candy.
Bad Influence
Our brownie-based Brookie finished with peanut butter drizzle.
PB Jelly Time
Peanut butter cookie with a jelly center, finished with nuts and peanut butter drizzle.
Third Wheel
Dates, peanut butter and chocolate make this a three-way combination worth keeping around.
Nutterbutter
Our homemade take on the familiar peanut butter sandwich-cookie favorite.
Miso Toffee Snickerdoodle
A snickerdoodle with white miso and homemade toffee for a sweet-and-salty twist.
Welcome to the Black Parade
A cookies-and-cream cookie built on a cream cheese base.
Drunk Dial
Peanut butter, Reese’s peanut butter cups and pretzels in one gloriously questionable decision.
Matcha
Matcha cookie dipped in white chocolate and finished with black sesame seeds.
Misery Bakes Almond Cookie
A Sicilian-style almond cookie, inspired by a classic Italian favorite.
Cream Of The Crop
Banana pudding, cookie-style.
>You're A Wizard Harry
A little magic for your cookie lineup in butterscotch form.
Breakfast Club
Coffee Talk
All the cozy appeal of coffee cake, reimagined as a cookie.
Tart Me Up Inside
A brown sugar cinnamon Pop-Tart-inspired cookie, because breakfast nostalgia deserves an encore.
Strawberry Pop Tart
A cookie inspired by the nostalgic strawberry Pop-Tart.
Breakfast of Champs
A Cinnamon Toast Crunch-inspired cookie for anyone who still considers cereal a personality trait.
Caffeinated + Questionable
Round of Chinos
A cappuccino-inspired cookie with white chocolate, finished with a dusting of cocoa.
Espresso Tini
Rum-based chocolate cookie dipped in white chocolate and topped with coffee beans.
Coffee Toffee
A coffee-flavored cookie with toffee bits, pairing a little bitterness with plenty of sweetness.
PB Espresso
A peanut butter cookie with a bold espresso twist.
A Little Unhinged / Sweet + Savory
Bad Decisions
Fig, dates and goat cheese in a cornflake cookie, finished with hot honey. It sounds like a dare, and we stand by it.
The Hail Mary
Potato chips and toffee come together for an unapologetically sweet-and-salty cookie.
Big, Stuffed + Sandwich Cookies
Big Back Peanut Butter
A chocolate-based cookie with a stuffed peanut butter center.
Pistachio Cream
A stuffed cookie built around a rich pistachio cream filling.
Yabba Dabba Doo
A jumbo vanilla cookie with white chocolate, Fruity Pebbles and marshmallow fluff.
The Red Zone
A jumbo red velvet cookie with white and semisweet chocolate.
Dip Dip Dip
A jumbo Dunkaroo-inspired vanilla cookie with white chocolate.
PB&J Cream Pie
A peanut butter cookie sandwich with a jelly-inspired cream filling.
Oatmeal Cream Pie
An oatmeal cookie sandwich with a cream filling, a nostalgic favorite in a bigger format.
Seasonal Damage
Not the Gumdrop Buttons
Gingerbread cookie decorated with royal icing.
White Chocolate Pumpkin Spice
A pumpkin-spice-inspired cookie with white chocolate.
Tonight, Tonight
A smashed brown butter pumpkin cookie. Simple, delicate, but highly addicting.
Monster Mash
Purple cookie with Oreos, chocolate, M&Ms & sprinkles.
Frankenstein Oreo Bar
Oreo cookie bar, all dressed up for Halloween.
Halloween Monster
Our brown butter sourdough base with chocolate and M&Ms, stuffed with a Halloween Oreo.
Not just cookies
Breakfast, bread + the rest.
The Cookie Vault gets a lot of attention, but we also make hand-rolled sourdough bagels, fresh bread and rotating bakes that belong at your next breakfast meeting, brunch or gathering.
- Normie bagels: $3 each, $16 for six, $30 for twelve
- Fancy Pants bagels: $4 each, $20 for six, $38 for twelve
- Classic sourdough bread: $10 per loaf
- Scones, muffins, sweet breads and seasonal specialties by request
- Mixed breakfast spreads and multi-loaf orders quoted individually
Normies
The classics, for good reason.
- Plain
- Salt
- Everything
- Garlic
- Sesame
- Poppy Seed
- Onion
Fancy Pants
When plain just isn't your thing.
- Jalapeño Cheddar
- Pumpkin
- Maple Brown Sugar Crunch
- Cinnamon Sugar Crunch
- Cinnamon Raisin
- Pumpernickel
- Salt & Vinegar Chip
- El Fuego (Chili Crunch)
- Rosemary & Sea Salt
- Italian Roasted Garlic
Bagel flavors are subject to availability, and custom assortments depend on order size and the baking schedule. Tell us what you're planning and we'll work out the options.


Custom quotes / Special requests
Got something else in mind?
We're happy to explore requests beyond the standard menu, whether you're imagining a new flavor combination, themed cookie assortment, branded gifts or an event spread with a very specific vibe. Tell us what you've got in mind, and we'll quote it based on the ingredients, quantities, timing and work involved.
- Specific flavors or made-for-your-event combinations
- Themed boxes, dessert trays and assorted spreads
- Individually wrapped favors, stickers and gift tags
- Corporate gifting and recurring team orders
- Specialty, stuffed, jumbo and sandwich cookie requests
Custom requests are reviewed individually and are subject to feasibility, schedule and applicable food-safety requirements. Packaging and delivery may add to the quote.
Here's how it works
Three steps, zero drama.
- Tell us the occasion.
Share your date, estimated guest count, preferred products and what you have in mind.
- We'll talk through the lineup.
We'll confirm flavors, four-per-flavor minimums for standard cookie selections, packaging and any special requests.
- Get your custom quote.
We'll confirm pricing, lead time, pickup or possible delivery, and next steps before the order is booked.
The boring but important stuff
A few things to know.
Lead time: Please reach out at least two days ahead when possible, with more notice for larger or customized orders.
Pickup + delivery: Pickup is in West Haven, Connecticut. Delivery may be available based on size, location and schedule, with fees quoted separately.
Availability: Flavors, quantities and dates are subject to confirmation. A request does not reserve your order until we confirm it, and larger custom orders may require a deposit or prepayment.
Custom packaging: Boxes, trays, individual wrapping, event stickers and gift notes may be available for an additional fee.
Allergens: Our kitchen handles wheat, eggs, milk, peanuts, tree nuts, sesame and other common allergens. We cannot guarantee an allergen-free environment, including for recipes that do not contain gluten ingredients.
Ready when you are
So, how many people
are we feeding?
Tell us the date, how many people you're feeding, what you're thinking about ordering and whether you need custom flavors or packaging. If you have absolutely no idea how much you need, that's fine too, we'll help you figure out the lineup.
Need recurring breakfast, employee treats or client gifts? Ask about standing orders and custom quotes.
BECOME A MISFIT
